Tuesday, August 2, 2011
You're a Penis-Packing, Less-than-real-woman, Man-in-a-dress.
That's really what it comes down to by some, isn't it? If you've charged through transition as much as you've been able and have not measured up to some mythical standard, you're likely to be called one of those things. Oh, and the list goes on: Faggot, tranny, freak, he/she... You get the point. I'll stop just because many of my own friends (including myself) have endured such name calling from those who they thought loved and cared for them. Many of us know what it feels like to be bullied by outsiders who cannot empathize with an incongruent gender/sexual identity. I've seen the bruises on bodies to prove it.
Sadly, those trigger-words aren't only being said by outsiders, but by the very people who claim to have walked more than a mile in your shoes. And just because they've "arrived" at being a "true woman," now they feel empowered to become the victimizer, belittling those very people who are already brutalized.
So how do you feel when someone who claims to have a transsexual history refers to you as a "man in a dress?" After all, everyone has to start somewhere. I remember the first few times I finally began to go out as my authentic self. I remember how ridiculous I looked. It wasn't so much that I looked and felt like a clown at the time, although I've been told that. Looking back I realize I was working through my own look like a young teenage girl practices and learns to wear the right amount of makeup. For a thirty-something transitioner, though, it was quite embarrassing at times. But I kept my head held high and deep confidence within me despite getting "read" for some time.
But that wasn't the end goal for me. I never wanted the END of transition to include others still seeing me as a "man in a dress." So even though I had a deep voice, I practiced my female voice day after day...after day. And I finally found my voice. I went through quite a bit of shopping before I learned what was appropriate and not appropriate to wear for a woman my age. I realized that it wasn't so much about having to learn to "be" a woman as it was to just allow myself to simply BE. And one day the reflection in the mirror matched exactly who I was inside.
I understand how painful being taunted can be. I've been ridiculed to no end. A close female relative once told me, "F*** anyone who has a problem with it. You be who you are because who you are is beautiful." Hearing those words, especially the F-bomb, come from her was a shocker since she never cursed. But she implanted a fire within me that would not easily be extinguished.
And that's why I'm terribly bothered when my friends are called hurtful names like "Penis-packers." Most of my trans - friends who have admitted they have not had sexual reassignment surgery also share the reason WHY they haven't had the surgery: they simply cannot afford surgery at the present time, might never be able to afford surgery because they are in an economically suppressed situation, or have some sort of health issue preventing them from having it. They don't delight in the fact they are "pre-operative" and struggle onward hoping the opportunity will present itself to have surgery.
And yet these same people take these words to heart...even if they're not lobbed directly at them, because every time they hear those poisonous words, they're faced with the sad fact that they can't yet have what so many others flaunt they've got.
I often use the term "Post-transition" for a reason. For one, I don't believe it's my business to point out to the world what someone else has between their legs. It's bad enough the "cisgender" world has an almost fetishistic craving to know, "Has she had the surgery? Is she post-op? I wonder what her vajayjay looks like!" And believe me, a lot of people think that way if you bring up SRS.
And yet, if you were to walk up to someone...anyone...a perfect stranger... who asserts he is male, would you ask, "Excuse me, sir, if you ARE a sir, that is. Would you kindly PROVE to me that you have a penis?" You'd likely get beat so blue you'd require stitches and a cast.
When the main focus of who we are is ALL about what type of surgery we've had, how can we expect the world to judge us for who we are as people and not instead fixate on whether or not an MTF is "penis-packin." It's as insulting as wondering what's between the legs of everyone who is not transsexual.
Having surgery is one of the highest achievements for those who need to and can obtain the means to see it through to the end. It signifies the closure of one part of their life and the path to a new horizon. There are those who have shown publicly their regret for surgery, but the stats show it is clearly the minority who regret their decision to have surgery. When each new friend heads off to Thailand, Scottsdale or San Francisco and returns elated that they are truly congruent with body, mind, and soul, I'm truly happy for them.
As for the majority of friends who share with me about the financial or physical dilemma they face, I do my best to be as supportive without belittling them or making them feel less than special. I'm no one. I've been fortunate to have been so blessed with wonderful friends who stood by me every step of the way.
It's a terrible shame that the bullies and victimizers out there have to come from within our own circles. This should never be so. Perhaps we should all take some simple advice: "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you."
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
20 comments:
It's not simply the labels though, but the attacks on reasons for not having GRS.
I can't presently have it for health reasons, though I'm fairly socially transitioned. When comments run that there are no conditions such as that, that I find far more hurtful than calling me a man in a dress which is just sheer nonsense. Same when someone opines that economic obstacles can all be overcome with the will to work harder. I, too, have friends for whom that sort of sentiment is deeply unfair.
Great post.
This is my first day at your blog and all I can say is a big THANK YOU!
I am non-op M2F
Doing the best I can
Lots of love to you
Marilyn
Lori. I want to commend and thank you for bringing up our "troubles" in such an open and forhright fashion.
Honestly. I do appreciate the opportunity that you have provided me to AGAIN TRY to make clear my feelings about this terribly difficult "condition", CLEAR.
Unfortunately I am not able to respond adequately at this time due to "real life", day to day matters. (I am up against a clock), but I promise that I will respond to this at some length in the very near future.
Again, Thank you for your forebearence.
Anne
I'm hoping that one day in our lifetime we can just remove the T in LGBT. And the LGB for that matter and replace all of them with H. After all we are all Human and we all deserve respect regardless of sexual identity or gender or what ever you have between your legs. It just does not matter. It's what is between your ears and your lungs that really matters.
You my dear friend are beautiful just for being you.
Thank you Lori!
I am truly sorry that you were the target of that vitriol. I know there are a few people out there who adhere to some idealized, rigid, and, I think, dangerous notion of what it take to be a woman or “truly transsexual”. I think of those folks as dangerously out of touch with themselves as well as what is happening in our movement.
While I have always felt uncomfortable with my male anatomy, I cannot deny how I was born and raised. I spent a lot of years in a closet, wrestling with fears and worrying about what others will think. When I finally moved on my own transition, I knew there would be compromises. I was and am not exactly like someone who was born female. I had a different anatomy and different social history. All of that is a part of who I am. I am a trans woman. Whether or not I have had a plumbing remodel does not define me. I think it is beyond cruel to suggest that standard for others. Jeeze, even the US Department of State has recognized this.
I wanted to transition a long time ago. I was turned down by the only provider I could find. In the old days (the mid 60’s) one could not even hope to transition within our medical system unless we could convince the gatekeepers of the times that we wanted to be a typical 50’s American housewife. I knew others, in the old days, who were able to develop a convincing narrative for the gatekeepers. Support groups as recently as 10 – 15 years ago often had discussions on how to convince a psychiatrist or psychologist that you fit the correct profile. (How developing a convincing lie would be good for any sort of therapeutic relationship is beyond me). Some folks who transitioned 40 years ago locked themselves into that belief system. There were no other ways, no other options. Our government and legal systems supported this. Without the “right” plumbing you were just not truly a man or woman. It did not matter what was in your head or heart. It did not matter what you knew to be true.
So . . . over the past twenty years there have been lots of positive changes. There is much more freedom for people to self-define. We are who we say we are. Yes, this can be confusing sometimes; just as it is confusing for others when we are early in transition. So what!
To suggest that there is only one way to be authentically a woman or transsexual doesn’t make sense. To attack someone who has done it courageously and beautifully; someone who is role model for others; someone who has offered support and understanding to others struggling with the journey is beyond mean.
I think it is important to see that this sort of “bullying” and bigotry exists within our community. We all can stand to work on our internalized transphobia. Thank you for standing up to this and for all of us.
@AZAlison
You wrote: There is much more freedom for people to self-define. We are who we say we are.
Respectfully, this is the kind of stuff that makes non-post-modernists like myself a little crazy. I was born with a discrepancy between brain and body. I needed to be female, so I did what had to be done to make that so. I didn't bend words or create new definitions to suit my reality. I dealt with reality as it exists.
I disagree with my friend Nikki. What's between our legs isn't the only thing that matters, but it definitely matters. It matters to me. It matters to my lover. It matters to women who have a right to female-only spaces.
I don't call people names. I don't ask whether people have had SRS. I won't dump on people for having medical or financial issues. There but for fortune go I. But neither will I ignore reality because it's inconvenient. As Philip K. Dick wrote, Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away.
Respectfully, Ariel, if "what's between our legs" matters to "women who have a right to female-only spaces", then it sounds like you are saying that anyone who was MAAB should not enter female-only spaces without prior genital surgery.
That seems very problematic to me, both from the point of view of excluding trans women with medical or financial issues from any sex-segregated spaces, and also from the point of view of allowing a comprehensive RLE before surgery.
I acknowledge that I'm speaking from the privileged position of having been FAAB, but in my experience, the women who have gone through transition are far more strident about a "no penises in here!" policy than those who were lucky enough to have been born with female genitalia. That seems a little ironic to me.
@Sonora Sage
I was actually thinking more of some lesbian feminist material I've read.
I do agree that a real RLE has to be possible. I went through it myself. But I restricted where I went -- pretty much only washrooms. I respected the privilege of being there. I didn't think I had a right.
Hi Kiddies... Gla to see that we are having just a lovely little love fest.
So, rather than rain on your parade, (although my bet is that you are all wishing that it would rain to cool thing down), I left my promised response on my blog where it will not intrude into your happy little world.
Please feel free to stop by for a read and leave a comment, (if dare..GRRRR) ;-)
Please, everyone. Anne has invited you over to her blog to see what kind of response she has crafted. Phrase head over there and read it. Just then you will see her true colors shining through. I'm not able to comment at length at the moment.
Please, everyone. Anne has invited you over to her blog to see what kind of response she has crafted. Phrase head over there and read it. Just then you will see her true colors shining through. I'm not able to comment at length at the moment.
Hey there,
I can't say that I've quite had the "prove to me you have a penis" comment in quite that fashion...but from the male side of the trans-fence that "how did you get one" or "how do you pee" etc, etc, etc sure does come up a lot.
There is entirely too much side-show fascination with trans-body-parts that keep us from being seen as normal humans.
The last time I was questioned about my body was by a gay man; I kindly pointed out to him that even amongst gay male crowds the first question one asks is not usually how big their dick is (*chat rooms excepted).
As for all of the swirl of who has the right to be what...
Ugh. Personally, I find this a horrific waste of time and energy. The rest of the world who is not and does not 'get' trans folks can't tell the difference between gays, drag queens and trans folks...let alone make a distinction between transsexual or transgender - or, if they're so inclined - will they care how much surgery someone has had, you'll still be a 'freak' to them.
I also suspect that this is generational - that the people who had to transition when the gates were narrow and restricted; in the age before the internet when information was hard to come by - those folks, like me, as I am one, are VERY strongly ID'd as their affirmed gender, were strongly driven and risked much to transition in the world at the time, and, were also forced to go stealth once done. I did for a decade. Transitions are still risky to do; it is still a difficult road, but there is much more information now, and many more choices in what and how people can choose to fit into the world as their gender. I think some of the most vitriolic are the ones who did what they did in a vacuum, with little to no support, and 'went away' to blend in to the hetero-normal world as was expected. They don't know and don't understand the movements that have been made over the last 20 years or so and don't see the potential future where transitions stop being a side show and really are just another slice of human diversity...in all of it's messy spectrum non-binary beauty.
Really surprised to see you taking the bait, Lori, but I'm glad you weighed in. Yours is a reasoned response, thoughtful. It's a pity that reason is inadequate to end this stupid battle over semantics. It would be nice if the privileged few quit pissing on the rest of us.
Lori, I am glad you wrote this piece. I think it is high time more of us spoke up against this strange need to elevate oneself by stomping on others. I have had my share of this. One example is this:
""So because YOU decided, after years spent cross dressing in the closet, while at the same time lying to your wife and fathering, (how many?), children, that now finally, after sex with "the old lady" wasn't as much fun any more, and the old "magic wand" just wasn't up to the job any more, YOU decided to, "what the heck", might as well "go all the way".
This was a comment left by Anne
My answer to it is here:
http://kathryn-martin.blogspot.com/2010_12_01_archive.html
This was just the beginning and it got worse. Presently there is this uneasy truce, but be sure it will come back with a vengeance.
Right on Lori. As a relative newcomer to T Central, looking for information, answers and discussions with other human beings with similar life experiences to mine, it didn’t take me long to find some of the “catty” comments from the “holier than thou” who feel that if someone doesn’t surgically “correct” their body to match their gender identity, let alone “transition,” that they are perceived as something less those who did have SRS and will always be a “man in a dress.” From those I get the same diatribe about how one will never know what it is to be a real woman unless they alter their body to match their perceived gender. Who cares? Doesn’t this “elitism” fit into the same short sighted, narrow minded bigotry that we get from outside the community, that we all so vigorously object to in regards to others failing to realize each and every one’s individual situation and needs. We hate to be pigeonholed from individuals who don’t look at us a people but wackos. Needless to say, it didn’t take me long either to start to not give a “rats ass” about what any from the top of the mount think. I guess it all boils down to what one feels is a woman or not. Merely a term and possibly a state of mind depending on what the individual thinks. I would like to believe that God couldn’t care less about such things, only what we make of our lives, the gifts we create and leave behind regardless of our gender, and how we affect others. I, myself, choose to follow a path where I will not seek surgery, and furthermore, not even transition to full time at any point during the years I have remaining. Why? Not because I’m in my 60’s, not because of fear, not because medical reasons, not because of finance, and it’s not because of lack of courage which I’ve read about from some as a weakness. But maybe it’s because of love. I’ve gone thru the same pain that I’ve heard over and over again about who I am, what I am and after years and years of anguish, I now know who I am. I can’t deny the thoughts in my mind and my feelings and I’m learning to love myself. But on the other hand, I have equal love for my wife, my sons and the rest of my life outside of being pegged into a gender of which the definition revolves around the earth as much as the moon. So for those of you high and mighty who look down on those that for their own reasons do not follow the same path as you, I couldn’t care less about what you think. I am my own person and, as a physician myself, I will always know that if it boils down to removing a penis, creating a vagina and other additional surgery to transform my body to make me feel whole and at peace with my world, so be it for you. But I am no less than you. I will not call you names like you may call me. I will not get into cat fights about who is what and who isn’t. I don’t need your help because along with it I’m sure there would be no concern or caring. And I do have to remind you that if it is changing your body that makes all the difference in the world, guess what….you’ll still always be an XY. No surgery can change that. Sorry!
Right on Lori. As a relative newcomer to T Central, looking for information, answers and discussions with other human beings with similar life experiences to mine, it didn’t take me long to find some of the “catty” comments from the “holier than thou” who feel that if someone doesn’t surgically “correct” their body to match their gender identity, let alone “transition,” that they are perceived as something less those who did have SRS and will always be a “man in a dress.” From those I get the same diatribe about how one will never know what it is to be a real woman unless they alter their body to match their perceived gender. Who cares? Doesn’t this “elitism” fit into the same short sighted, narrow minded bigotry that we get from outside the community, that we all so vigorously object to in regards to others failing to realize each and every one’s individual situation and needs. We hate to be pigeonholed from individuals who don’t look at us a people but wackos. Needless to say, it didn’t take me long either to start to not give a “rats ass” about what any from the top of the mount think. I guess it all boils down to what one feels is a woman or not. Merely a term and possibly a state of mind depending on what the individual thinks. I would like to believe that God couldn’t care less about such things, only what we make of our lives, the gifts we create and leave behind regardless of our gender, and how we affect others. I, myself, choose to follow a path where I will not seek surgery, and furthermore, not even transition to full time at any point during the years I have remaining. Why? Not because I’m in my 60’s, not because of fear, not because medical reasons, not because of finance, and it’s not because of lack of courage which I’ve read about from some as a weakness. But maybe it’s because of love. I’ve gone thru the same pain that I’ve heard over and over again about who I am, what I am and after years and years of anguish, I now know who I am. I can’t deny the thoughts in my mind and my feelings and I’m learning to love myself. But on the other hand, I have equal love for my wife, my sons and the rest of my life outside of being pegged into a gender of which the definition revolves around the earth as much as the moon. So for those of you high and mighty who look down on those that for their own reasons do not follow the same path as you, I couldn’t care less about what you think. I am my own person and, as a physician myself, I will always know that if it boils down to removing a penis, creating a vagina and other additional surgery to transform my body to make me feel whole and at peace with my world, so be it for you. But I am no less than you. I will not call you names like you may call me. I will not get into cat fights about who is what and who isn’t. I don’t need your help because along with it I’m sure there would be no concern or caring. And I do have to remind you that if it is changing your body that makes all the difference in the world, guess what….you’ll still always be an XY. No surgery can change that. Sorry!
pidgeonholes,labels, t-envy,when will it end?
I really enjoyed reading this well written piece and agree with you pretty much all the way.
When you look at it like this,people have and extrordinary fixation on other peoples "bits"!!!
@IWBY - So true....(referring to your last paragraph)
Lori, I'm sorry you had to go through that. I've had that experience in a totally different realm, and I chalk it all up to just plain snobbery. Following you and being able to chat with you shows me that you are a DAUGHTER of God, whether others see that or not. You know who you are, and the people that count, whether trans or cis, are the ones who don't care what's there.
Keep your hands up and remember your identity in all of this. Make sense?
Thank you. You're viewpoint in this essay is powerful, and rings full of provocative truths.
Post a Comment